Two former ambassadors have offered Canada a cautiously hopeful assessment of its difficult trade relationship with the United States: a new agreement may be possible, but tariffs and political uncertainty are unlikely to disappear overnight.

Their comments to a Canadian parliamentary committee on Monday, 16 November 2026, come amid efforts to repair economic ties between Ottawa and Washington. The key question is whether Canada and the United States can reach a trade deal—and what such an agreement would actually change.

What did the former ambassadors tell Parliament?

David Cohen, a former US ambassador to Canada who served under President Joe Biden, told the House of Commons Standing Committee on Foreign Affairs and International Development that he remained optimistic about the relationship.

Cohen said the two countries had been close to an agreement before negotiations broke down in August 2026. He argued that the depth of the economic relationship still provided a basis for renewed cooperation.

David MacNaughton, Canada’s former ambassador to the United States during the first Trump administration, gave a more guarded assessment of the negotiating environment.

He urged Canada to pursue a durable arrangement with Washington while simultaneously diversifying trade and improving domestic productivity.

The two perspectives are not necessarily contradictory: both saw value in rebuilding trade ties, but they differed in emphasis on the risks and limits of a return to the previous relationship.

Does a possible trade deal mean US tariffs will be lifted?

A new agreement would not automatically mean every tariff disappears.

Cohen cautioned that changes in the makeup of the US Congress after the 2026 midterm elections would not necessarily produce the votes required to overcome a presidential veto on tariff legislation.

That means tariff decisions could remain influenced by the White House, even if lawmakers are more skeptical of the administration’s trade policies.

The practical significance for Canadian exporters depends on the exact terms of any future agreement: which products it covers, which duties it changes and what exemptions or enforcement mechanisms are included.

Until a deal is formally announced, predictions about specific tariff reductions remain provisional.

What is happening with CUSMA?

The Canada–United States–Mexico Agreement (CUSMA) is the principal framework governing much of the three countries’ trade.

Canadian Press reporting says the Trump administration chose in July 2026 not to renew the trilateral arrangement under the review process, setting up further talks and a sequence of possible annual reviews.

The review mechanism means uncertainty over the longer-term framework can continue even if Canada and the United States conclude a separate bilateral understanding.

Businesses therefore face two related but distinct issues: the possibility of a near-term trade accord and the more complicated future of the three-country agreement.

Why is this issue receiving new attention?

The ambassadors’ testimony followed renewed discussion of trade negotiations under Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney and US President Donald Trump.

The political situation has also changed following the US midterm elections. Cohen described the results as a rebuke to the administration’s policies, while cautioning against assuming that Congress could quickly overturn the tariff framework.

For Canada, the relationship remains economically consequential because supply chains, investment and major industries span the border.

Uncertainty is especially important for manufacturers and exporters making decisions that depend on predictable market access.

What did MacNaughton recommend for Canada?

MacNaughton’s response focused on three complementary priorities: negotiate with the United States, diversify Canada’s trade relationships and strengthen Canadian productivity.

Diversification could reduce dependence on one destination for exports, but building new commercial relationships takes time and may not substitute for existing cross-border supply chains in the near term.

Improving productivity likewise addresses longer-term competitiveness rather than providing an immediate solution to current duties.

These recommendations represent the former ambassador’s policy assessment, not a new government programme announced at the hearing.

Is a Canada–US agreement imminent?

There was no completed bilateral deal to announce following the 16 November testimony. Cohen expressed optimism, but the unresolved details of tariffs and the broader CUSMA review remained significant.

For businesses and consumers, the next decisive development will be an official announcement outlining enforceable terms rather than an estimate of how close the negotiating teams may be.

The central message from the former ambassadors is cautiously positive but conditional: a Canada–US trade agreement is possible, while managing tariffs and long-term trade uncertainty will require more than one diplomatic breakthrough.