A midwife told the New South Wales Coroners Court on 19 November that she advised a Hunter Valley mother expecting twins to give birth in hospital. One of the twins died after a homebirth attended by midwives. The evidence came two days after the same inquest heard about a different twin pregnancy in northern NSW, where the birth took place without a registered midwife. What has the court heard about the two cases, and why does the distinction between homebirth and freebirth matter?

What the court heard about the Hunter Valley homebirth

The midwife told the court she recommended a hospital birth so emergency care would be available if needed. According to ABC News, the court heard that the nearest specialised maternity hospital was about two hours away. The mother went ahead with the planned homebirth with midwifery assistance.

The court heard evidence that the infant, identified as Baby B, died following an infection with group B streptococcus. Midwifery expert Professor Hannah Dahlen told the inquest she did not consider the homebirth directly responsible for the death. She said the infection can also occur after a hospital birth. The advice about where to give birth and the expert opinion about what caused the infant’s death address separate questions that the court is examining.

What differed in the earlier twin case?

On 17 November, the court heard about Baby D, who died hours after being born at home in northern NSW in February 2024. His twin was stillborn. ABC News reported that no registered midwife attended the birth. The evidence heard in that case was that the twins would probably have survived if their mother had received antenatal care.

In the reporting on this inquest, freebirth refers to giving birth without the attendance of a regulated maternity professional. The Hunter Valley birth, by comparison, was attended by registered midwives. Australia’s Pregnancy, Birth and Baby information service lists a twin pregnancy among the circumstances in which a doctor or midwife will recommend hospital birth.

What happens next in Lismore?

Deputy State Coroner Joan Baptie is examining four neonatal deaths. The Coroners Court lists the hearings in Lismore through 27 November. The two twin pregnancies have brought different evidence before the court. The Hunter Valley hearing focused on hospital advice, a planned homebirth and an infection. The earlier northern NSW case raised questions about access to antenatal care before a birth without a midwife. The inquest is continuing.