Sixteen large retailers have received failing grades in a new assessment of how companies manage hazardous chemicals and plastics in the products they sell. The 2026 Retailer Report Card, published on November 18 by the nonprofit Toxic-Free Future, says nearly half of comparable retailers have moved backwards on chemical-safety policies since 2024.
Which stores appear in the “Toxic Hall of Shame”, why did some major chains lose ground, and does a failing grade mean that their products have been proven dangerous? The answers depend on understanding what the assessment actually measures.
Which retailers are in the 2026 Toxic Hall of Shame?
Toxic-Free Future awarded an F grade to 16 of the 50 retailers it evaluated in the United States and Canada. Its public announcement specifically identifies several companies among those receiving failing marks:
- Trader Joe’s, McDonald’s and 7-Eleven, which the organization says also received F grades in 2024.
- Wayfair and Williams-Sonoma, which were among the businesses newly included in the 2026 evaluation.
The headline figure is 16 failing grades, or about one-third of the companies assessed. Readers seeking to compare every chain should consult the complete scorecard and retailer-by-retailer results, rather than assume the five examples above form the full list.
The phrase “Toxic Hall of Shame” is the advocacy group’s name for the lowest grade category in its own scoring system.
Which retailers scored highest for chemical safety?
The 2026 report also recognizes businesses that adopted more extensive policies and disclosures relating to chemicals and plastics.
According to Toxic-Free Future:
- Apple received an A, the highest grade in the report.
- IKEA, Target and Sephora each received an A-.
- Dollar Tree was named the most improved retailer, with a score increase of 16 percentage points since 2024.
These results refer to the group’s assessment of corporate policies, goals, transparency and documented progress. They should be understood within the scoring framework, not as blanket safety certifications for every item sold by the named businesses.
Why did Walmart and Whole Foods lose ground?
Walmart and Whole Foods Market experienced the largest score declines compared with 2024, according to the report. Each fell by at least 20 percentage points.
The group says 22 of the 45 retailers assessed in both 2024 and 2026 experienced a decline of at least two percentage points. That represents 49% of the companies for which a direct comparison was available.
Toxic-Free Future also notes a timing qualification concerning Whole Foods Market: the retailer disclosed additional progress shortly before the report was published, after the evaluation period had ended. According to the organization, this information would have earned extra points had it been submitted within the scoring window.
That matters because the rankings capture evidence available during a defined assessment period. They are not necessarily a real-time inventory of everything a retailer has changed since then.
What does a failing F grade actually measure?
The Retailer Report Card evaluates companies’ chemicals and plastics policies and their implementation, rather than certifying the safety of every individual product on a retailer’s shelves.
Toxic-Free Future describes its criteria as covering corporate responsibility, transparency, restrictions on hazardous chemicals or plastics, and movement towards safer alternatives.
Its researchers used publicly available information and material supplied by retailers. The organization says all 50 companies had an opportunity to review preliminary scores and provide feedback or additional information.
An F grade therefore signals poor performance against this particular nonprofit scoring rubric. It should not be interpreted as proof that every product at a named retailer contains a harmful chemical, nor as a regulatory finding that the company violated a specific law.
Likewise, a high grade indicates stronger performance under the report’s criteria; it does not replace independent safety evaluation for a particular product.
Which chemicals and materials are central to the report?
The assessment focuses on retailer action to identify, restrict and replace substances and materials of concern. The organization’s examples include:
- PFAS, a broad family of persistent chemicals used in some packaging, cookware and textiles.
- Bisphenols, some of which have been used in thermal receipt paper.
- PVC, a plastic found in certain products and packaging.
Specific health risks depend on the substance, the degree and route of exposure, and other factors. The report concerns policies intended to reduce potentially hazardous exposures across products and supply chains; it is not a set of individual medical diagnoses.
The organization points to Washington state’s restrictions on toxic bisphenols in receipts, effective in January 2026, as an example of regulation influencing retailer practices.
Have retailers made measurable progress since 2024?
Several reported indicators suggest a setback in public commitments and disclosure.
Only 10% of retailers in the 2026 evaluation had measurable public goals to reduce or eliminate toxic chemicals and plastics, compared with 44% in 2024, Toxic-Free Future says.
The share reporting actual progress in reducing or eliminating chemicals or plastics also fell:
- 2024: 68%, or 34 retailers.
- 2026: 44%, or 22 retailers.
Meanwhile, the overall average grade remained D+.
The figures describe the nonprofit’s scoring and reporting exercise. They do not by themselves quantify changes in measured chemical exposure among customers.
What should consumers take from the 2026 report?
For shoppers, the most useful distinction is between what a retailer says it will do, what it documents having done and what is known about an individual product.
A corporate scorecard can reveal differences in transparency and chemical-reduction commitments. Product-specific ingredient disclosures, independent testing, recalls and official safety notices address different questions and may be necessary for a purchasing decision.
The 2026 report’s main conclusion is that 16 retailers received failing policy grades and nearly half of comparable chains scored worse than in 2024. It also records examples of stronger performance by Apple, IKEA, Target and Sephora.
The “Toxic Hall of Shame” label is designed to attract attention, but its practical meaning lies in the report’s methodology: an assessment of how retailers manage and disclose chemical-safety policies, at a particular point in time.
All grades and comparisons are attributed to Toxic-Free Future’s 2026 Retailer Report Card, released November 18, 2026.